Everyone should be treated the same

Strongly

Agree

Agree

Neutral

Disagree

Strongly

Disagree

9 cases sorted by Top scoring

Against

stealthbeast almost 5 years ago

Treating people the same is not the same as treating people equally. Not everybody has the same needs.

Good point (11)

Against

JoiFoote1 almost 5 years ago

While on face value this appears to be a plausible statement, I think this fails to recognise the difference between equity and equality. The former recognises that individuals are subject to many different circumstances, which means that equality does not always produce a fair result. If we treat everyone the same that would be giving two individuals the same resources without taking into account said circumstances. Instead, we need to treat people in regard to their situation. An individual coming from a lower socio-economic background would have less access to resources than another from a higher socio-economic background. As such it would be unfair to treat them equally in light of this.

Good point (5)

Against

beccaofangmar almost 5 years ago

Equity not equality.

Good point (3)

Against

barracuuda almost 5 years ago

Not everyone should be treated the same for two reasons.

The first reason is because of the difference between equality and equity. Everyone should have equal opportunity, but every individual is unique and do not have equal access to opportunity. Some people need extra support. This would not be possible if everyone were treated the same.

The second reason is for the choices people can make. Certain people do not deserve to be treated as though they are equal because their choices and ideals do harm to others. Nazis, murderers, rapists, and the like are worse and should be treated worse so they are not normalized and accepted by society.

Good point (3)

Mixed

Turi over 5 years ago

These statements (#MaC) form part of the Morality as Cooperation Quiz

What is morality? Where does it come from, and how does it work? And how and why do moral values vary, between individuals, and across cultures?

The theory of ‘morality as cooperation’ (MAC) argues that morality is best understood as a collection of biological and cultural solutions to the problems of cooperation recurrent in human social life. MAC draws on evolutionary game theory to argue that, because there are many types of cooperation, there will be many types of morality.

These include: family values, group loyalty, reciprocity, heroism, deference, fairness and property rights. Previous research suggests that these seven types of morality are evolutionarily-ancient, psychologically-distinct, and cross-culturally universal.

Take the Quiz to work out what your particular mix looks like.

See more

Good point (2)

Against

Finnick almost 5 years ago

we need equity not just equality

Good point (1)

Commentary

Onion over 4 years ago

This is interesting, what if a person has contributed a lot to society?

Good point (1)

barracuuda almost 5 years ago

[This comment was deleted by its author]

Commentary

Llamasrule (edited) 4 years ago

If only the government could see all this and finally step up to balance, by bringing what the people NEED. Not what those idiots WANT.

Good point